Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between The Fives Beach Hotel and The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort is the best fit.
Best for families, couples, and friend groups who want a lively beachfront all-inclusive-style stay in Playa del Carmen with lots of dining, pools, kids’ programming, and room to spread out.
Better for travelers who want a quieter ultra-luxury Riviera Maya resort experience in Kanai, with polished service, refined design, and a more serene, high-end atmosphere.
If you want a social, all-ages beachfront resort with many restaurants and bars, multiple pools, a kids’ club, teen spaces, and easy Playa del Carmen access, The Fives Beach Hotel is the stronger fit.
If your priority is a more elevated luxury escape with a calmer pace, contemporary architecture, and a secluded Kanai setting, The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya is the better choice.
Bottom line: choose The Fives Beach Hotel for a livelier, family-friendly beach resort with all-inclusive convenience; choose The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya for a quieter, more refined luxury stay.
| Category | The Fives Beach Hotel | The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Lively all-ages beachfront resort in Playa del Carmen with a broad dining lineup, several pools, family programming, and a social vacation feel. | Refined Riviera Maya luxury resort in Kanai with a quieter, more polished atmosphere and a stronger focus on design, service, and relaxation. |
| Location | On Xcalacoco beach in the Playa del Carmen area, about a 40-minute drive south of Cancún International Airport and a short drive from downtown Playa del Carmen. | Set in Kanai on the Riviera Maya, better suited to travelers who want a more secluded, upscale resort setting rather than a Playa del Carmen beach-town feel. |
| Rooms & Suites | Apartment-style accommodations and suites that work well for families and groups who want practical space, resort amenities, and easy beach access. | More refined luxury rooms and suites with a sleeker, high-end feel—better for couples and travelers prioritizing design, calm, and service. |
| Dining | Extensive restaurant and bar variety, with Mexican and international options including Italian, Thai, Japanese, French, Peruvian-inspired dining, casual bars, and beach/pool venues. | More upscale, destination-luxury dining style, better for travelers who prefer a refined culinary setting over a broad all-inclusive-style resort lineup. |
| Pools & Beach | Direct beachfront setting with several outdoor pools, including family-friendly areas and an adults-only pool within the resort. | A calmer Kanai beach-resort scene with a more serene pool and beachfront atmosphere, suited to lounging, quiet service, and luxury relaxation. |
| Kids & Family | Strong family setup with Aluxitos Kids Club for ages 4–12, a Teens Club, children’s activities, and all-ages resort energy. | Welcomes families, but the atmosphere is more luxury-resort calm than activity-heavy family resort, making it especially appealing for couples and quieter family trips. |
| Price & Value | Best value for travelers who want dining variety, beach access, kids’ programming, entertainment, and an inclusive-style resort experience in one place. | Best value for travelers who are willing to pay for a more exclusive-feeling luxury stay, refined service, and a quieter Riviera Maya setting. |
Rooms and suites at The Fives Beach Hotel are geared toward travelers who want space, comfort, and easy access to a full resort setting. The property works especially well for families and groups.
The Fives is the better pick if you want a more active, all-ages resort base with room to spread out and plenty happening around the property.
The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya delivers a more elevated room experience, with a calmer luxury feel and a stronger sense of privacy and design.
If you want a quieter, more luxurious room experience in a secluded Riviera Maya setting, The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya has the edge.
Dining at The Fives Beach Hotel is one of its biggest advantages, with a wide mix of Mexican and international venues plus casual bars, poolside drinks, and beachfront settings.
Expect:
The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya is better suited to travelers who want a more refined dining atmosphere rather than a large all-inclusive-style circuit of venues.
If you want the widest range of casual and international dining choices, The Fives Beach Hotel is usually the easier fit; if you want a more elevated dining mood, choose The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya.
The Fives Beach Hotel sits directly on the beach in the Playa del Carmen area and offers a multi-pool resort setup that works well for families, couples, and groups.
The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya offers a more serene pool and beach experience, with the feel of a quieter luxury retreat rather than a busy family resort.
If you want more pool energy and family-friendly beach-resort activity, choose The Fives; if you want calm, polish, and a more exclusive-feeling beachfront setting, choose The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya.
Family programming is a major reason to choose The Fives Beach Hotel. The resort is all-ages and offers dedicated children’s and teen amenities.
The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya can work for families, but its personality is more refined and relaxation-focused than activity-packed.
If kids’ clubs, teen spaces, and a lively all-ages resort matter most, The Fives Beach Hotel is the more natural choice.
The Fives Beach Hotel offers the strongest value when you want a full-service beachfront resort with lots of dining variety, family amenities, pools, and entertainment bundled into one stay.
The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya is the better value if your priorities are luxury design, quieter surroundings, attentive service, and a more exclusive resort atmosphere.
Choose The Fives if you want an all-ages beachfront resort with kids’ programming, teen amenities, multiple pools, lots of dining variety, and a lively Playa del Carmen-area setting.
The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya is the better pick for travelers who want a quieter, more refined luxury stay in Kanai with polished service and a more serene pace.
For families and groups who want convenience, entertainment, and a resort that keeps everyone busy, The Fives Beach Hotel is the more practical and social choice.
If you want a more exclusive-feeling Riviera Maya escape with a calmer beach scene and a stronger luxury-resort identity, The St. Regis Kanai Resort, Riviera Maya wins.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for The Fives Beach Hotel:
